Why You Should Not Be a Consultant

Written By: Eric Kimberling
Date: January 14, 2022

I've been a consultant for 25 years now, and I'm here to tell you that it is not what you think it is. Back in the late 1990s, I started my career, unwillingly as a consultant. I found a job at Price Waterhouse after coming out of grad school, and it turned out I really enjoyed consulting. Having said that, there's a lot of reasons why you should not be a consultant, but to be fair, there's a lot of reasons why you should as well.

Pro: You Make an Impact

To start, let's talk about the positive aspects of being a consultant. First and foremost, as a consultant, means having a big impact on organizations. Working internally at an organization and having the same skillset, will provide you with an edge in the internal team. If you're an outside consultant with the same skillset, you’re the expert.

What companies typically hire consultants because they want to go through some sort of change, and they're looking for direction and advice. Through this business transformation, they need a coach.

As a consultant you will impact how big, massive, influential organizations throughout the world operate. That can be very exciting. For example, many of the clients we work with at Third Stage are for-profit companies that produce excellent resources. They manufacturer amazing products. Others are nonprofits that are furthering society, and government entities that are helping people. There's a lot of indirect end results that are beneficial within this role and career.

YouTube player

Pro: Challenging and Rewarding

Most of the issues that consultants are asked to fix are very challenging but rewarding. There are complex problems that need to be solved, almost always while on the job. The constant learning of new industries, how businesses operate, operational, organizational, and technology dynamics will give an edge to the competition. It really is a space where mastering it may never come full circle but having the experience and working with all kinds of people, go a long way.

The benefits out way the cost.

Pro: Foundation for Future Career Growth

By being a consultant, it will oftentimes set the foundation to be successful in whatever career you might pursue post consulting. If you have worked with helping some leading organizations throughout the world solve complex problems, you're going to be a lot more marketable, and desirable to other businesses. There is a possibility in the future you don't want to be consultant anymore. Travel is tiring, the stress is overwhelming, and long hours catch up to you, whatever the case may be, the background is important.

Pro: Trend Setting Technologies

Now, if you're intrigued by emerging technologies, as I am, consulting can be fascinating to learn. As I mentioned before, you’re constantly learning about new industries, businesses, and cultures. Whether it’s artificial intelligence, data analytics, robotics, machine learning, or ERP systems, you're constantly forced to learn so you can have that knowledge to advance your skillset.

Being on the cutting edge of where technology is headed and understanding how technology works within complex organizations is very important to the growth of being an effective consultant.

YouTube player

Con: Hard Work

I just talked about some of the good aspects of consulting, however there are many downsides and risks associated with this career path as well. First, it’s a lot of hard work.

Professionals that lack strong work ethics or can’t sustain long hours, don't typically succeed in consulting. If you value the 40 hour-work weeks, and 8:00 to 5:00 work-life balance, and weekends off, and holidays off all the time, consulting may not be the best.

There's a lot of pressure that comes with the job as well. Client demands that can catch up to you and if you're not prepared for that, or if you don't want to work hard, it's not going to be a good fit for you. If you're really value a lifestyle balance, or work life balance, more than career exposure and long-term growth potential, then consulting is not the right choice for you.

Con: Politics

If you've watched my videos for some time, or you've gone deep into my YouTube channel, you've probably seen me talk about some of my experiences working for the big system integrators. A downside, in my opinion, would be the big consulting firms in the industry. If I were to summarize what some of those challenges trace back to, a lot of it is politics, especially for the larger consulting firms like Deloitte, Accenture, KPMG, and Capgemini.

There's a deep seeded political dynamic that can be very unhealthy and stressful. Which was the case for me. That was the main reason why I left the larger consulting firms. They typically are focused on protecting big revenue streams with big clients and projects. When there's that much money at risk, it drives a lot of unhealthy political dynamics internally within the consulting organization.

To give you a couple examples, oftentimes you aren't completely transparent with the clients because that revenue stream needs to be protected. I know I spent a lot of hours and meetings with other team members trying to figure out how we were going to put a positive spin on really bad news. We spent most of our resources on trying to make ourselves look good, rather than focusing on how to solve the client's problems.

This can be a very stressful thing if you're not ready for that, or if you don't like that sort of ecosystem. In my case, I didn't like it, so that's why I moved on. Politics and the stress that comes from them, can be enough to keep you away which is understandable for some individuals.

YouTube player

Con: Client Problems Are Your Problems

No matter how irrational it may seem, whenever a client has a problem, it becomes your problem. As a consultant, there are high expectations. Customers have some sort of problem that they don't feel like they can address themselves, so therefore, they're hiring you as a consultant.

Oftentimes, this situation is very difficult and stressful because the client has some other dynamics at play that are undermining their abilities to solve this specific issue.

For example, organizations that are trying to implement new technologies, don’t know how to deploy them. It's not because the consultants don't know how to deploy technology either, it's actually because there's internal, political fighting, and an unhealthy culture. There are broken operational processes and things wrong with the organization that isn't necessarily the fault as a consultant, but it becomes their problem because now you've got to figure out how to solve this problem that you didn't create and have little control over.

Many consultants really struggle with that dynamic. I always try to set expectations with consultants we hire, by saying that if you want to be a good consultant, and you want to be effective, you need to think about how you can be a better therapist to your clients.

Ultimately, the value of consulting is listening to and understanding your client's problems.

Con: Soft Skills

One of the biggest keys to success is what I often refer to as, the finesse of consulting. It's more of an art rather than science. That is the soft skill of consulting.

When I was first starting my career in my early twenties as a consultant, there's a lot I didn't know. There's still a lot I didn't know, but I knew even less back then. One of the ways I overcame that lack of knowledge and experience, was by really mastering my finesse and knowing how to ask questions, read clients, and becoming somewhat of chameleon that can effectively adapt to different situations.

Those soft skills are something, they're very difficult to teach and if you don't have them, it could be very difficult to master or develop. It’s like trying to teach someone to be a good singer. They can rehearse, learn to read music, etc. – but ultimately, they need to have some natural talent. It is all great to have the hard, tangible, technical skills, and understanding of business processes, but do you also have those soft skills? If there are a lack of soft skills, or demonstrating those soft skills, you may want to rethink a career in consulting.

Con: Slow Pace of Advancement

Now, the final disadvantage I'll point out here is the fact that for many larger consulting firms, the pace of advancement is very slow. You must demonstrate a certain amount of tenure before you can move up within the organization. In fact, I grew very impatient, especially being in my early to mid-twenties, early in my career, to where I felt like I could do a lot more than what I was being allowed to do at one of the big consulting firms.

If you're looking at one of these massive consulting firms and value quick upward advancement, be sure you really think through that dynamic. Big consulting firms are designed to ensure that no one fails on the project.

They've really mastered this whole science of bringing in college grads that don't know what they're doing and putting them in a position where they can't fail. Part of this assurance process is slowing upward movement of employees. The big tech companies are going to make sure that you move up only after you're 100% prepared for that next step in the process. If that's something that does not sound appealing or you value challenging yourself, the good news is there is an option. You can go to a smaller or mid-tier consulting firm.

The challenge there, of course, is if you don't have consulting experience, it's going to be harder to get a job with one of those firms. This something to keep in mind as you consider a career in consulting.

Bottom Line: Is Consulting Right for Me?

This all begs the question, is consulting right for me? It honestly just depends (spoken like a true consultant) on your personality and what your goals are. If you like to work hard, you have those soft skills that help you be an effective consultant, you like to learn, you're interested in different types of businesses and problem solving, consulting could be a great career.

However, if you like more drawn to predictability and stable work environments, then consulting may not be a good career for you.


I hope this has given you a sense of whether consulting would be the right fit for you. I encourage you, if you are interested in learning more about consulting for a company like Third Stage, I've included our recruiting contact information here. For more information on more of a deep dive of consulting and what It takes to become one, you can check out our 2021 Digital Transformation Report. If you have any questions regarding consulting or your career path, please don’t hesitate to reach out to me directly. I am happy to be an informal sounding board as you move through your digital transformation journey.

YouTube player

FAQs About Consulting as a Career

Is consulting a good career?

There are definite positives to being a consultant. First of all, you can make a real impact within an organization with your specialized skills. Secondly, there might be a lot of challenges, but the job can be equally rewarding. Thirdly, working as a problem solver with renowned organizations would add more to your resume and make you more marketable as a professional. The negatives are limited but worth considering. Your clients can be demanding, working in a big and integrated system can expose you to internal politics, and you have to work really hard to make a name for yourself. Overall, the pros overshadow the cons and if you do choose to pursue a career as a consultant, it can present a world of opportunities for you. If you're selft-start motivated by an entreprenural environments, consulting is a very rewarding career choice. If you are interested in joining the Third Stage Consulting team, please reach out to us at work@thirdstage-consulting.com.

Should you become a consultant?

Consulting can be a challenging career path, however, if you have the right skill sets and an attitude for it, it can be a lucrative career choice and a chance to work for some of the world’s biggest firms. If you are ready to work hard and learn through different processes and businesses, have the decipline to manage a fast-paced work environment, and love problem-solving, then think no more. Consulting is the right career choice for you. On the other hand, if vaule standerdization, consitency, and are drawn to predictable work days, consulting many not be the best choice for you.

What is it like to be a consultant?

Working as a consultant usually involves a lot of travelling and working long hours on the project to project basis. It is a common practice to work extra hours to meet strict deadlines or handle extremely demanding projects. If you want to make a career in consulting, then you must be really passionate about your job and enjoy working outside of the working hours as well. However, the world over, all major firms are realizing the importance of work-life balance and are increasingly providing a more conducive work environment.

How to know if consulting is for you?

Consulting often involves working long hours, spending extra working hours travelling extensively, dealing with demanding clients, and working within strict deadlines. However, you garner experience of working across systems and learning quickly. If you enjoy a work environment that is constantly evolving and learning new industries, consulting is a great choice. For professionals with the required talent, consulting can be a rewarding career that will not only provide you with the opportunity to work with some of the biggest global firms but also offer exciting professional new adventures.

Be sure to download the newly released 2023 Digital Transformation Report to garner additional industry insight and project best practices.

Also download our Supply Chain Management Playbook here.

Kimberling Eric Blue Backgroundv2
Eric Kimberling

Eric is known globally as a thought leader in the ERP consulting space. He has helped hundreds of high-profile enterprises worldwide with their technology initiatives, including Nucor Steel, Fisher and Paykel Healthcare, Kodak, Coors, Boeing, and Duke Energy. He has helped manage ERP implementations and reengineer global supply chains across the world.

Eric Kimberling
Eric is known globally as a thought leader in the ERP consulting space. He has helped hundreds of high-profile enterprises worldwide with their technology initiatives, including Nucor Steel, Fisher and Paykel Healthcare, Kodak, Coors, Boeing, and Duke Energy. He has helped manage ERP implementations and reengineer global supply chains across the world.
Subscribe for updates
We never share data. We respect your privacy
Stratosphere 2024
Register Here
Additional Blog Categories



International Office Locations

Follow us on:

Third Stage Consulting

Third Stage Consulting Group is a global thought leader in business transformation, ERP software systems, operational change management, and business advisory. Let us take your organization’s digital transformation to the Third Stage.
2022 - Copyright Third Stage Consulting Group LLC  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Website developed and maintained by Denver Web Design.
Privacy Notice  |  Terms of Use  |  Sitemap